This browser doesn't support Spotify Web Player. Switch browsers or download Spotify for your desktop.

What Were They Thinking?

By Nathan & Brendan

Nathan and Brendan discuss truly awful movies while trying to keep their sanity in tact. Full disclosure: We may be in love with the movies we deem terrible. New episodes uploaded every second Thursday! Mailbag and mini episodes every other Thursday! Logo created by Mariah Lirette. Theme song by Taylor Sheasgreen.

  1. 1.
    Episode 40 - Magic in the Water (w/Mariah Lirette)22 February 2018
    1:35:55
  2. 2.
    Interview: Sam Firstenberg (”American Ninja,” “Ninja III: Domination,” “Breakin’ 2: Electric Boogaloo”)15 February 2018
    1:05:58
  3. 3.
    Episode 39 - My Bloody Valentine 3D8 February 2018
    1:39:31
  4. 4.
    Episode 38.5 - Way Too Young1 February 2018
    40:23
  5. 5.
    Episode 38 - Tammy and the T-Rex (w/Kaleigh Stultz and Steve & Izzy from “Everything I Learned from Movies”)25 January 2018
    1:43:04
  6. 6.
    Interview: Kelli Maroney (”Chopping Mall,” “Fast Times at Ridgemont High,” “Night of the Comet”)18 January 2018
    1:04:27
  7. 7.
    Episode 37 - Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III (w/Dame Malcolm Wallace)11 January 2018
    1:51:06
  8. 8.
    RETRO: The Garbage Pail Kids Movie4 January 2018
    1:34:58
  1. 9.
    Episode 36.5 - Butt Stuff28 December 2017
    33:16
  2. 10.
    Episode 36 - Silent Night, Deadly Night: Part 2 (w/Jessica Cameron)21 December 2017
    1:21:53
  3. 11.
    Episode 35.5 - Christmas, Yo!14 December 2017
    38:39
  4. 12.
    Episode 35 - Surviving Christmas7 December 2017
    1:38:11
  5. 13.
    Mailbag #9: Luigi Mario (w/Joshua Kotsabasakis)30 November 2017
    37:29
  6. 14.
    Episode 34 - Spawn (w/Joshua Kotsabasakis)23 November 2017
    1:49:55
  7. 15.
    Episode 33.5 - FACT, Not Opinion16 November 2017
    35:10
  8. 16.
    Episode 33 - Gamera vs. Gyaos9 November 2017
    1:26:36
  9. 17.
    Mailbag #8: Celebri-pedes2 November 2017
    38:07
  10. 18.
    Episode 32 - The Human Centipede (w/Mariah Lirette)26 October 2017
    1:23:53
  11. 19.
    Interview: Robyn Paris, Carolyn Minnott & Dan Janjigian from “The Room”19 October 2017
    54:58
  12. 20.
    Episode 31 - Mikey12 October 2017
    1:30:22
  13. 21.
    Mailbag #7: The Works of Stephen Kong5 October 2017
    30:04
  14. 22.
    Episode 30 - King Arthur: Legend of the Sword (w/Steve from Everything I Learned From Movies)28 September 2017
    1:43:10
  15. 23.
    Episode 29.5 - Where’s the Mailbag?21 September 2017
    38:52
  16. 24.
    Episode 29 - The Demons of Ludlow (w/Gary Spavold)14 September 2017
    1:31:02
  17. 25.
    The 1st Annual What Were They Thinking Manos Hand-Outs7 September 2017
    1:12:38
  18. 26.
    Episode 28 - Pearl Harbor (w/Jason MacLeod)31 August 2017
    1:28:45
  19. 27.
    Mailbag #6: Brendan Can’t Drive (w/Matthew Pettifer)24 August 2017
    38:02
  20. 28.
    Episode 27 - GI Joe: Rise of Cobra (w/Matthew Pettifer)17 August 2017
    1:40:07
  21. 29.
    Mailbag #5: Hangin’ With My (Michael) Bae10 August 2017
    30:56
  22. 30.
    Episode 26 - Bad Boys II3 August 2017
    1:48:34
  23. 31.
    Mailbag #4: Jackin’ it in the Booth27 July 2017
    38:20
  24. 32.
    Episode 25 - The Lone Ranger20 July 2017
    1:37:28
  25. 33.
    Mailbag #3: Summer Edition13 July 2017
    34:20
  26. 34.
    Episode 24 - Uncle Sam6 July 2017
    1:33:54
  27. 35.
    Mailbag #2: Back in the Habit29 June 2017
    32:08
  28. 36.
    Episode 23 - The Crazies22 June 2017
    1:26:08
  29. 37.
    Mailbag #115 June 2017
    38:13
  30. 38.
    Episode 22 - Ben & Arthur (w/Mariah Lirette)8 June 2017
    2:00:23
  31. 39.
    Episode 21 - Law Abiding Citizen26 May 2017
    1:31:04
  32. 40.
    Episode 20 - Killer Klowns from Outer Space12 May 2017
    1:19:08
  33. 41.
    Episode 19 - Listener’s Choice #4: Rollerball (w/Jerika Layne)27 April 2017
    1:36:33
  34. 42.
    Episode 18 - Listener’s Choice #3: Nick Fury: Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D (w/Joshua Kotsabasakis)20 April 2017
    1:17:13
  35. 43.
    Episode 17 - Listener’s Choice #2: Monkeybone13 April 2017
    1:32:39
  36. 44.
    Episode 16 - Listener’s Choice #1: Garbage Pail Kids6 April 2017
    1:25:04
  37. 45.
    Episode 15 - Ready to Rumble (w/Ryan Gilbert)23 March 2017
    2:02:54
  38. 46.
    Episode 14 - Wrestlemania XI (w/Jason MacLeod)9 March 2017
    1:36:34
  39. 47.
    Episode 13 - American Ninja23 February 2017
    2:05:28
  40. 48.
    Episode 12 - Captain America (w/Joshua Kotsabasakis)9 February 2017
    1:37:39
  41. 49.
    Episode 11 - Criminal26 January 2017
    1:43:59
  42. 50.
    Episode 10 - Nine Lives12 January 2017
    1:40:24
  43. 51.
    Episode 9 - Ernest Saves Christmas (w/Mariah Lirette)25 December 2016
    1:22:57
  44. 52.
    Episode 8 - Silent Night, Deadly Night8 December 2016
    1:37:10
  45. 53.
    Episode 7 - Gamera: Guardian of the Universe24 November 2016
    1:32:29
  46. 54.
    Episode 6 - The Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl10 November 2016
    1:30:47
  47. 55.
    Episode 5 - Critters27 October 2016
    1:36:51
  48. 56.
    Episode 4 - Thrashin’ (w/Jerika Layne)13 October 2016
    1:39:11
  49. 57.
    Episode 3 - Judgment Night29 September 2016
    1:18:32

Listen to What Were They Thinking? now.

Listen to What Were They Thinking? in full in the Spotify app