The band set about recording its debut EP with Bitchin' Bajas' Cooper Crain in 2014. The process took just a day for recording and a day for mixing. The resulting six-track Pennsylvania EP drew comparisons to the Breeders and Lightning Bolt, as it combined the rock-focused melodicism of the former with the chaotic noise of the latter. Melkbelly continued to hone their sound with a series of singles, and 2015 saw the release of the abrasive tracks "Piss Wizard" and "Bathroom at the Beach." In 2016 they teamed up with Dave Vettraino to record the 7" "Elk Mountain" and "Mount Kool Kid" at Chicago's Public House.
Taking a more leisurely approach to what would become their debut long-player, they once again teamed up with Vettraino and wrote much of the record in the studio, tracking it to eight-track analog tape. Melkbelly appeared at SXSW in 2017 as part of a Carpark Records showcase, and despite their late arrival -- due to a 26-hour drive plagued by vehicle issues -- the band's set was received enthusiastically by the press. Their debut record, Nothing Valley, appeared in October 2017, and it marked the first release for Sadie Dupuis' (Speedy Ortiz) Wax Nine Records, a sister label to Carpark. ~ Bekki Bemrose, Rovi