- 01 All I Want For Christmas Is You (Glee Cast Version) 04:04
- 02 Extraordinary Merry Christmas (Glee Cast Version) 03:39
- 03 Santa Baby (Glee Cast Version) 02:32
- 04 Christmas Eve With You (Glee Cast Version) 03:28
- 05 Little Drummer Boy (Glee Cast Version) 02:56
- 06 River (Glee Cast Version) 04:03
- 07 Do You Hear What I Hear (Glee Cast Version) 03:52
- 08 Let It Snow (Glee Cast Version) 02:47
- 09 Santa Claus Is Coming to Town (Glee Cast Version) 02:50
- 10 Christmas Wrapping (Glee Cast Version) 04:03
- 11 Blue Christmas (Glee Cast Version) 03:49
- 12 Do They Know It's Christmas? (Glee Cast Version) 03:25